Director: Mike Nichols
Cast: Robin Williams, Gene Hackman, Nathan Lane, Dianne Wiest
Have I Seen it Before: Oh, sure. I have the vaguest recollection of twenty-plus years ago talking to a… “friend” seems like such an alien term these days… who was as conservative as Oklahoma is mishapen, who loved the film because it made fun of gay people.
Honestly, I could make a whole book out of right-wingers completely missing the intent of any film.
Did I Like It: But that may be part of the film’s strength, or at least why it has managed to live a relatively long life, where other comedies have aged like milk. Every character has within them a measure of the dignified and the ridiculous. If you’re going to make a comedy and not include that quality, then the best you can hope for is that the audience has the same axe to grind as you. With the quality, even if the laugh isn’t always there, at least you can be confident that a laugh will be around the corner.
Thankfully, I never have to be concerned about the next laugh as the film unfurls. The cynic among us might say that the film has not much more than a sitcom plot, something that would have been at home within an above-average episode of Frasier, but I think that’s the element to which Nichols and May responded. It was a perfect empty vessel of a farce, and they could fill it with good performances and say more than a few things about the absurdities of both people and life in the mid-90s that those of us in the 2020s could probably stand to remember.
And then, improbably, beyond the one-liners and broad comedy, a political thesis rises to the top. Anyone who claims they have a monopoly on the family doesn’t understand the first thing about it.
Maybe we need another remake of it today.
